At Anime Weekend Atlanta, people dress up in costumes the way they do at Dragon-Con, but today, I learned they maybe a little more extreme.
As I was walking around meeting vendors to promote STEAMfest, there was a person dressed in a German Officers Uniform. I am vaguely inured to that. The big swastika arm band however, was shocking.
Even more shocking was the astonishing number of people who said "Oh How Cool! Let me get your picture!"
Let me make this perfectly clear: People were clamoring to take pictures of and have their picture taken with someone wearing what's supposed to look like a World War II Nazi Uniform with a swastika!
Some quick history: The Nazis were Germans and their followers who believed that people existed for the state and that Aryan people had a natural right to dominate over others including taking their property and supporting the mass engineered execution of literally 12 million people in the Holocaust.
There is a difference between wanting to dress up as Darth Vader & wanting to dress up as a Nazi officer. Darth Vader is fictional. The Nazis were real. Darth Vader is ultimately redeemed. The Nazi leadership went to their ends unrepentant. They thought that killing 6 millions Jews, just for being Jewish, half a million Roma, 3 million other Poles and Russians, 15 thousand gay people and more helped make the world a better place.
When you put on that uniform and when you choose to wear the swastika, you are saying you agree. This is not a play. This is walking around in public. More troubling than the teenager who thought this was a good idea are all the others who thought that such a uniform was 'So Cool!'. Let it also be noted here that there were other 'German Officers', but the Swastika is what drew the attention and the fans and it is the Swastika which identifies you as a Nazi. Yes. I am aware that Nazis are the villains in certain Anime, but again, their the villains because their ACTUALLY evil and when you put on the clothes, you take the ideology with it. This isn't Star Wars, the Nazis had a very specific idea of what should happen and they thought they were entitled to kill you.
What made this kid's parents think that it was okay for him to go out in public as a Nazi? What led these other kids to want to have their picture taken with that?
Can you imagine if someone had shown up dressed as a Ku Klux Klan Wizard? As Osama Bin Laden? As Jean Kambanda? One would think there would have been outrage. Apparently, over Nazis there is none. Kids are down with the killing.
The question is now what to do about it? It's not an isolated incident. A play about Anne Frank had to be stopped last year at a north Fulton County school when the kids started cheering for the Nazis. The cast and school officials were shaken.
What AWA should not do is ban the costume. Censorship here will not help. It will only make Nazism forbidden fruit, which is the sweetest of all. Nor should they ban 'offensive costuming' (though the AWA costume rules do have a decency clause).
What they might want to do is add something to their costume rules requesting that nothing outright offensive be worn (not insisting, requesting) & they might want to add a panel about fictional evil, which people can reasonably want to play around with, and actual evil in which the true impact and effects of the carnage are shown and manifest.
Think about it. What would you do if your son, daughter, sister, brother, or cousin said 'Hey! I am going to go out to an event with thousands of people dressed as a Nazi officer! Come with me! Let's take pictures and put them on internet!" Would you not go to any lengths to stop this?
This is the Banality of Evil at its heart. You should want to stop it, because if you don't, pretty quickly, you'll be next!
As I was walking around meeting vendors to promote STEAMfest, there was a person dressed in a German Officers Uniform. I am vaguely inured to that. The big swastika arm band however, was shocking.
Even more shocking was the astonishing number of people who said "Oh How Cool! Let me get your picture!"
Let me make this perfectly clear: People were clamoring to take pictures of and have their picture taken with someone wearing what's supposed to look like a World War II Nazi Uniform with a swastika!
Some quick history: The Nazis were Germans and their followers who believed that people existed for the state and that Aryan people had a natural right to dominate over others including taking their property and supporting the mass engineered execution of literally 12 million people in the Holocaust.
There is a difference between wanting to dress up as Darth Vader & wanting to dress up as a Nazi officer. Darth Vader is fictional. The Nazis were real. Darth Vader is ultimately redeemed. The Nazi leadership went to their ends unrepentant. They thought that killing 6 millions Jews, just for being Jewish, half a million Roma, 3 million other Poles and Russians, 15 thousand gay people and more helped make the world a better place.
When you put on that uniform and when you choose to wear the swastika, you are saying you agree. This is not a play. This is walking around in public. More troubling than the teenager who thought this was a good idea are all the others who thought that such a uniform was 'So Cool!'. Let it also be noted here that there were other 'German Officers', but the Swastika is what drew the attention and the fans and it is the Swastika which identifies you as a Nazi. Yes. I am aware that Nazis are the villains in certain Anime, but again, their the villains because their ACTUALLY evil and when you put on the clothes, you take the ideology with it. This isn't Star Wars, the Nazis had a very specific idea of what should happen and they thought they were entitled to kill you.
What made this kid's parents think that it was okay for him to go out in public as a Nazi? What led these other kids to want to have their picture taken with that?
Can you imagine if someone had shown up dressed as a Ku Klux Klan Wizard? As Osama Bin Laden? As Jean Kambanda? One would think there would have been outrage. Apparently, over Nazis there is none. Kids are down with the killing.
The question is now what to do about it? It's not an isolated incident. A play about Anne Frank had to be stopped last year at a north Fulton County school when the kids started cheering for the Nazis. The cast and school officials were shaken.
What AWA should not do is ban the costume. Censorship here will not help. It will only make Nazism forbidden fruit, which is the sweetest of all. Nor should they ban 'offensive costuming' (though the AWA costume rules do have a decency clause).
What they might want to do is add something to their costume rules requesting that nothing outright offensive be worn (not insisting, requesting) & they might want to add a panel about fictional evil, which people can reasonably want to play around with, and actual evil in which the true impact and effects of the carnage are shown and manifest.
Think about it. What would you do if your son, daughter, sister, brother, or cousin said 'Hey! I am going to go out to an event with thousands of people dressed as a Nazi officer! Come with me! Let's take pictures and put them on internet!" Would you not go to any lengths to stop this?
This is the Banality of Evil at its heart. You should want to stop it, because if you don't, pretty quickly, you'll be next!
Leave a comment
